… making it required to have an active end-cap-level toon in the guild. we want to know how you feel about this as we take it into consideration as a potential shift in /ginvites.
in other words, reaching a point somewhere in the near-not-too-distant-future where you would need to have a level 70 (currently) toon that is in the guild and is active (i.e. not offline for a month). in order to join the guild, you would need to have a 70 to bring in, or have to get to 70 within a short period (perhaps from 60). at ‘implementation of the reg’, all characters at or above level 50 would have x amount of time to get to 70, gear and begin raiding and all others (under 50) would have y amount of time to do same — to accommodate all of our valued members now that are not currently in possession of a 70 in our guild.
we have grown a fair amount in the past several months and are rapidly reaching the point where we need more 70s that are active in the guild in order to meet expanding raiding needs (we need more raiders). requiring that newcomers join with a 70 or that they reach 70 shortly thereafter fosters a larger pool of 70s from which to draw on to fill raids. and it means we can do more of the same raids as well as more raids instances.
it also increases the number of 70s online and available to work together in non-raid instances, craft items, pvp and do dailies.
it reduces the situation (reduces to zero) where people use our guild to level to 70 and gear up, then leave to go to another guild “where their main is” (that would not level them up and gear them up) and leave behind yet another alt they want us to help level and gear (which then leaves also). we are not a farm team for other guilds to level their alts in.
it reduces the number of players that would request lowbie (e.g. VC) run throughs repetitively from higher level toons without being in a position to return the favor (to anyone).
there are downsides to the concept: what if you have a friend that wants to move to this server and start a new toon and play with us (you)? they would not have a level 70 on the server nor would a short leveling period necessarily be fair. if we make an exception for them, why aren’t we making exceptions for other friends you have on the server that just started out? or that have 70s in tier 6 raiding guild but would level a new toon in ours and keep it there?
putting in place a reg that keeps us from /ginviting unless they have a raid-level toon crimps growth of the guild size; however, not necessarily crimping where most of us are focused.
the number one reason for attrition (departures) from our guild over the past 12 months has been that they are leaving to help/play with a brother/friend/whatever and the number two reason is that they did not find enough 70s online to group with to get XYZ done.
not much we can do about reason #1 and we wish them all well. reason #2 gets resolved with more 70s online which is a factor of how many 70s we have and how many are online at similar times. increasing the number of 70s is conducive to more 70s online, which is conducive to more 70s grouping to get XYZ done.
while we are indeed enjoying a growth in our guildie numbers, reducing attrition is always healthy. on the other hand, restricting recruiting has the potential to reduce our growth which could lead to a reduction in guild roster if attrition exceeds growth.
no decisions have been made yet, and we are seeking your thoughts and feelings on this matter. you all have the opportunity to affect this decision. of course, nothing is set in stone and all can be reversed; however, we tend to like getting it right the first time around.
please talk to a senior officer or your guild leader and share your opinions candidly. we are eager to hear your arguments in favor and against.